Optimism
Malthouse Melbourne
Voltaire’s Candide might be one of the most important and influential writings of all time. An adventure tale told as a sarcastic parody, the story follows a young man’s spiralling disillusionment with the philosophy of optimism.
"The ensemble acting is fantastic ... the biting satire of Candide is not to be found"
Tom Wright’s Optimism is more of an original theatrical work inspired by Voltaire’s story than an adaptation. Here, we see Candide, energetically played by Frank Woodley, thrust into a quest for happiness and his true love. This quest takes him to numerous cities and puts him on many planes, all of which are signposted by five monitors that are suspended above the stage.
There is no denying the absolute skill and talent that is on display here. The ensemble acting is fantastic, with everyone, save Woodley, playing multiple roles in this all-singing, dancing, drama and comedy-fuelled clown show. And director Michael Kantor has come up with a production filled with interesting images filled with imagination.
But the production as a whole feels like it has little substance. It is nothing more than a vehicle for a big-name comedian and a bunch of shenanigans. While that is not a bad thing, it does mean that the biting satire of Candide is not to be found. In the first act, the final scene – a poignant moment mixed with comedy, tragedy and heartbreak – shows the promise of a far greater show. The second act fares better, but this is nowhere near as great a production as it could have been.
Optimism is a fun production filled with great images and some inspired performances. However, its lack of emotional depth prevents it from either getting under the audience’s skin or in leaving much of a lasting impression.
From August 15 2009 to August 17 2009 at Royal Lyceum, Edinburgh (part of Edinburgh International Festival). Tel: 0131 248 4848. www.lyceum.org.uk
www.eif.co.uk/optimism
Comments:
Have you seen this production? What did you think?Be the first to join the debate.
Sorry, you aren't signed in right now. You must be a member of the site to post your comments. You can sign in on the left-hand side of this page. If you aren't a member yet, why not sign up now? It only takes a couple of minutes.
What the papers said:
The Herald:
**** "A rollicking good night out, only slightly diminished by some odd changes of pace"
**** "A rollicking good night out, only slightly diminished by some odd changes of pace"
The Guardian:
*** "For all its wild, inventive energy, the real problem with [Michael] Kantor's production is that it wants to dazzle and please too much"
*** "For all its wild, inventive energy, the real problem with [Michael] Kantor's production is that it wants to dazzle and please too much"
The Scotsman:
**** "Brilliantly entertaining and sometimes inspired"
**** "Brilliantly entertaining and sometimes inspired"
Scotland on Sunday:
"[Frank Woodley gives] a delightful, funny performance, but one that is countered too rarely with the darkness and anger needed to make the satire sting"
"[Frank Woodley gives] a delightful, funny performance, but one that is countered too rarely with the darkness and anger needed to make the satire sting"
Share this review:

Subscribe to RSS feed